Night 5

[Total Ullz]

I think we should:
Kill Squink
Redirect Sister Coyote to Peeker

[Total Ullz]

Alive:
I. total ullz
II. cookies
IV. sistercoyote
VI. peeker
VII. hockey monkey
VIII. texcat
IX. paranoia
XI. renata
XII. storyteller
XVII. guiri
XVIII. brewha
XX. mister blockey
XXI. crazypunker
XXII. catinasuit
XXV. metallic squink
XXVI. special ed

Dead:
XIX. sachertorte - Tracker
V. pleonast - vanilla
XIV. mhaye - Mason
XV. mahaloth - Scum Roleblocker
XXIV. rysto - third party survivor
XIII. Inner Stickler - vanilla
III. billmc - Mason
XVI. naf1138 - Scum Godfather
X. suburban plankton - vanilla
XXIII. charr

[Total Ullz]

If we make the kill toNight we're starting Day 6 with
11 townies (assuming no other 3rd)
1 Hockey Monkey
3 scum

I'm hoping we can lynch crazy toMorrow - but we can't be sure.
But I'll do my best to push for that lynch and the lynch of Hockey Monkey.
If we're lucky that would buy CatInASuit some time

Then (hoping we get the kill through) Day 7 will be
9 townies
1 Hockey Monkey
3 scum

I want to know what you both think of me trying to dig up the posts of CatInASuit Day 7???
In this game it seems very risky and people seem to be very willing to be "lead" to the lynch. So if I push too hard CatInASuit might get lynched.
On the other hand - it's starting to look a bit strange that I'm completely ignoring the case...

[renata]

I think that works, the orders so far. Squink will surely not roleblock me again, so the kill should go through, anyway.

[catinasuit]

just checking in.
Agree with renata killing squink and ulla redirecting sis C to peekercpa.

I'll think of someone to track in due course, there aren't that many candidates left.

[renata]

You might be able to push on CIAS, Ulla; it's not like there aren't other candidates about for the lynch. If it's him, then yuck in one sense, but it costs us little power-wise at this point,and you could get some town cred. If it's someone else, even better. Just be careful with your wording,of course.

[catinasuit]

Ok, I have updated the Knowledge of the Dark and it still makes grim reading .

Looking at it, we still need to engineer 5 mislynches to get the game.

16 players - 6NK - 5 mis = 5 (3 scum, 2 town) assuming HM does get lynched and we win after an NK

If Hockey Monkey is not lynched, then it's
16 players - 5NK - 5 mis = 6 (3 scum, 2 town, 1 3rd) and we win following a mislynch.

Regardless we still need to generate 5 more mislynches and generating 9 mislynches in a game to win?? ouch.

Assuming all goes well tonight, it is likely to be a straight lynch fight between crazypunker and myself tomorrow.

If anything goes wrong, I will be claiming doctor, as it is reasonably possible the roles does not exist in the game setup. If it does, then hopefully it should flush out the real doc to be dealt with. I shouldn'e be upset really, aiming into the unknown pool did flush out an investigative role as I has hoped. Just a shame that, they got spotted the Night before.

Also, be extra nice to squink. That roleblock on Night 0 prevented Ulla from being spotted by Sis C when she didn't redirect from Ed to peekercpa. Oh wait, that's tonight's kill. ;D

Of course, I just know that having planned this, something will bite us in the proverbial. Here's hoping otherwise.

[catinasuit]

Ok, Night action, these to choose from:
II. cookies
VIII. texcat
XVIII. brewha
XX. mister blockey
xXXVI. special ed

Mister B hasn't been around much, but his vote on Mahaloth has pinged me somewhat

I wonder if Ed is a power considering his comment back to Squink about suspicion and his attacks on storyteller. He knows he has a get out card if worst comes to worst.

texcat, I'm unsure of but leaning vanilla, dito for brewha

cookies? I never can tell with cookies.

Hmm

Oh why not,.

CIAS to track Mr Ed

Renata to kill metallicsquink

[catinasuit]

I'm an idiot, we have a Doc Claim which makes it really really likely that we don't have a doc in the game at all.

I have updated the thread with a list of all the Night Targets that it would have reasonable to protect and still be clear of everything.

The temptation is now to claim and have one of you two counter claim doc. One of us will die, but the other would be pretty much confirmed in everyone else's eyes

Let's keep that as a back up plan shall we.

[Total Ullz]

ToMorrow I was thinking of trying to get Crazypunker lynched. The last post he made Day 5 to me about pinging him justifies me looking more closely at him. At Day 6 any player looked at can have something thrown at them

Redirect Sister Coyote to Peeker

[Total Ullz]

Don't know where that color came from

Redirect Sister Coyote to Peeker

[catinasuit]

I have had a horrible thought.

If metallicsquink blocks renata again and Sis C looks in the same direction, we will have an outed scum for no Night Kill. Also if SisC is not looking at peekercpa with have a problem anyway as it would indicate a redirect.

Now, strictly speaking, Sis C should be looking at peekercpa and Squink should be blocking someone else, but is it worth making sure?

The choice is in making sure we get a kill through vs controlling where Sis C looks. renata should still be carrying out the kill but the choice is between.

redirect SisC to peekercpa
redirect squink to squink (ie. a self block)

Also: there is the choice of redirecting squink to SisC, which would raise all sorts of questions in the morning, but would probably give a hint of a redirector as well.

Ulla, it's your choice.

Horrible thought over, if SisC looks at squink and we control the redirect, she gets the two of you for squink's death.

Ignore me.

[catinasuit]

and the only other amusing thing is a New Year resolution to conribute more to the game HAS got me into more trouble. Typical.

[renata]

At this point I think our only realistic chance is a higher than average number of neutral parties (like, 5 competing survivors, or some such) reducing our mislynch burden.

Doctor counterclaim is quite interesting. Only problem is there's no real excuse for a claimed (and "proven", at that) doc to live for very long. We could probably string it out a couple of days, though, with careful choice of kill order and redirects.

[renata]

The counterclaimer could say they'd been sitting on Metallic Squink or Guiri for whatever nights SisC was watching peeker, and peeker otherwise, I suppose.

[bufftabby]

Track, kill, redirect confirmed.