Knowledge of the Dark

[catinasuit]

Those of the Light
Confirmed-ish
VI. peeker - Light Mason
IV. sistercoyote - Light Watcher
VII. hockey monkey - Third Party Survivor
XXV. metallic squink - Light Roleblocker
XXI. crazypunker - Light Scotsman Vanilla
XII. storyteller - special


Unconfirmed
II. cookies
VIII. texcat
IX. paranoia - likely vanilla
XVIII. brewha
XX. mister blockey
xXXVI. special ed
XVII. guiri - likely vanilla

Those of the Dark
I. total ullz - Wheel of Fortune - Dark Redirector
XI. renata - The Empress - Dark Vanilla
XXII. catinasuit - The High Priestess - Dark Tracker


Those passed on
XIX. sachertorte - The Hierophant - Light Tracker
V. pleonast - The Tower - Light Vanilla
XIV. mhaye - The Moon - Light Mason
XV. mahaloth - The Lover - Dark Roleblocker
XXIV. rysto - Judgement - Third Party Survivor
III. billmc - Light Mason
XVI. naf1138 - The Emperor - Dark Godfather
XIII. slicker intern - The World Light Vanilla
X. suburban plankton - Ace of Pentacles Light Vanilla
XXIII. charr - Light Vanilla

Tracking results:
BillMc - nothing
guiri - nothing
paranoia - nothing
storyteller - nothing
sistercoyote - spent night with peekercpa

[catinasuit]

Setup.

Here is my initial guess at a setup, rough JSexton added

Town (19)
1 investigator (4)
1 doc (3)
3 Masons (7.5)
1 watcher (2)
1 Tracker (2)
1 Roleblocker (2)
11 Vanilla (11)
Score 31

Scum (5)
godfather (7)
roleblocker (6.5)
redirector (7)
tracker (6)
vanilla (4.5)
Score 31

PFK (2)
2 competing survivors

Updated best guess given the game

Town (19)
3 Masons (7.5)
1 one-off bodyguard type (2) ??
1 watcher (2) - found
1 Tracker (2) - found
1 Scotsman (2) - found
1 Roleblocker (2) - found
1 special (2??) - found
10 Vanilla (10)
Score 29.5

Scum (5)
godfather (6) - vs watcher only
roleblocker (6.5)
redirector (7)
tracker (6)
vanilla (4.5)
Score 30

PFK (2)
2 competing survivors

If you discount the Night start then it becomes a lot more even.

On the flipside, I think we may have uncovered all the town power roles bar one. I really hope bufftabby has gone for the fun and games and not included a detective or a straight doctor.

[renata]

From CIAS's tracking results: Guiri and Bill did nothing on nights 1 and 0, respectively; and hence are unlikely to be protectors or investigators of any kind. Roleblocker is possible, as is mason.

[naf1138]

Turns out Bill is a mason.

Other things we have found out so far today:
Story has a post restriction. Probably a power role.

[renata]

Could also be something that was done to him -- visible sign of a mad bomber, for instance. (Or a hypothetical and in the event non-existent scum power.) He seemed to talk just fine yesterday.

[naf1138]

Dec 7, 2010 15:38:01 GMT -6 renata said:

Could also be something that was done to him -- visible sign of a mad bomber, for instance. (Or a hypothetical and in the event non-existent scum power.) He seemed to talk just fine yesterday.

I am starting to think along those lines too. I am wondering if we don't have a vote buyer in the group. Charr voted for no reason, then story says he hates shoes and I am thinking they might be connected. It makes more sense than for Charr to just drop a bad vote like that, and story's post does make it seem that the restriction is a recent development.

[renata]

Add paranoia to the "probable non-power" list along with Guiri, based on Cat's tracking result.